Unsolved Cases

Timothy Wiltsey

On May 25, 1991 five year old Timothy Wiltsey disappeared from a carnival in Kennedy Park on Washington Road. Almost one year later his remains were discovered in a creek bed in a remote area of Edison, NJ. There has been an indictment and arrest in this case.

Timothy WiltseyUPDATE: On January 5, 2017  Middlesex County Superior Court Judge Dennis Nieves sentenced Michelle Lodzinski, the former South Amboy resident convicted of killing her 5-year-old son, Timothy Wiltsey,  to 30 years in state prison.


Nancy Noga

Nancy NogaOn January 7, 1999, Nancy Noga, age 17, was reported missing by her family. On January 12, 1999, her body was found behind the Mini-Mall located at 499 Ernston Road in Sayreville, NJ.

We are asking if anyone has any information pertaining to Nancy’s death, to please contact Det./Sgt. Thomas Cassidy at (732) 525-5406 or Det. Matthew O’Such at (732) 525-5487. You can also call the Sayreville Police Department’s main number at (732) 727-4444, or contact unsolved@sayrevillepolice.org

As always, all information will be kept strictly confidential.

This case is actively being  investigated.